An ImportExportTools NG alternative
ImportExportTools NG is the well-known export add-on for Thunderbird, used by almost 300,000 people. ThunderExportImport is newer and smaller, with a different focus: verifiable, stamped exports that keep working across Thunderbird versions. Here is the honest comparison.
Side by side
Figures from addons.thunderbird.net and each add-on's own files and listing, checked on 12 October 2026. “Not listed” means the listing doesn't mention it. Corrections welcome on GitHub.
| ThunderExportImport 1.1 | ImportExportTools NG 15.0.3 | |
|---|---|---|
| Basics | ||
| Price | Free | Free |
| License | MIT | GPL 3.0 |
| Thunderbird versions (current release) | 91 → any newertwo builds: 91–139 and 140+ | 140 – 157 older versions for older Thunderbird |
| Experiment APIs (deep access to Thunderbird internals) | None | 6 |
| Download size | ≈ 80 KB | 633 KB |
| Daily users (ATN) | new | 287,000 |
| Export | ||
| EML, HTML, plain text, MBOX | ✓ | ✓ |
| ✓ own PDF writer: text, Western European characters | ✓ | |
| Attachments, subfolders, file name patterns, CSV index | ✓ | ✓ |
| Everything in one ZIP | ✓ | not listed |
| Compliance stamp (exported by, date, Message-ID, SHA-256, QR code) | ✓ | not listed |
| SHA-256 manifest and Verify | ✓ | not listed |
| Runs in the background, progress on the toolbar button | ✓ | not listed |
| Export search results, copy to clipboard | – | ✓ |
| Import and backup | ||
| Import EML and MBOX | ✓ into a folder (Thunderbird 106+), duplicates skipped | ✓ MBOX with folder structure, EMLX too |
| Import a ZIP | ✓ | not listed |
| Profile backup and restore | – | ✓ with schedule |
| Settings backup of other add-ons | ✓ Thunder suite | – |
Which one should you use?
ThunderExportImport
You need exports others can trust (stamp, SHA-256, verify), a tidy ZIP per job, or support on Thunderbird versions from 91 to the newest with one add-on.
ImportExportTools NG
You need profile backups, MBOX imports that rebuild folder trees, EMLX import or search-result exports.
They can be installed side by side.
Sources: the addons.thunderbird.net page for ImportExportTools NG and its public API data; the Experiment API count from its manifest.